Follow us on Facebook
0

Scott Colom's election is tied to the legacy of 1964 Freedom Summer, says writer-in-residence at the University of Mississippi

Mississippi Today Ideas is a platform for thoughtful ideas to be shared about our state’s past, present and future. Opinions expressed in guest essays are the author’s own and do not necessarily represent those of Mississippi Today. You can read more about the section here.


“Like other Southerners, Mississippians are obsessed by their sense of the past, but this does not ensure the accuracy of their historical picture,” historian James W. Silver once wrote as an analysis of the cultural ethos of the Magnolia State in his book “Mississippi: The Closed Society.”

He went on to note that when looking at their past, Mississippians “see legend rather than history.” Written in 1962, Silver, then a faculty member at the University of Mississippi, compiled his observations of Mississippi in the aftermath of the violence that occurred during the integration of Ole Miss. His painfully accurate depictions of the culture of Mississippi prompted state officials to launch an effort to fire him from the university even though he was a tenured faculty member. In the aftermath of the book’s publication, Silver found himself harassed, threatened and ostracized, and eventually he left Mississippi.

James Silver’s mid-20th-century portrait of the worldview of segregated Mississippi has been on my mind of late as Democrat Scott Colom was elected as the first African-American U.S. senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction.

‘Lost Cause’ mythology

While it is an historical fact that Colom will be the first elected Black senator since Blanche K. Bruce in 1881, Bruce’s service as Mississippi’s senator has been seen by most Mississippians more as legend than historical fact. The story of Reconstruction in the South has been wrapped in a narrative of failure, warped by images from D.W. Griffith’s “Birth of a Nation” and the Dunning School of historians who framed the service of senators like Bruce as illegitimate. This interpretation came to be the basis of the “Lost Cause” narrative that rationalized lynching and led to a Jim Crow system of segregation that controlled Black citizens economically, socially and politically.

In a culture that prizes memory of the Civil War through the lens of the Lost Cause over the realities of the Reconstruction era – Mississippi still observes Confederate Heritage Month each April – Bruce’s time as Mississippi’s senator is surrounded with forgetfulness and consigned to a footnote.

Mississippi Summer Project 

There is a stronger connection between Colom’s win and the goals of the Mississippi Summer Project in 1964, commonly known as Freedom Summer. White Mississippians long took pride in the effective practice of the art of politics. Part of that practice meant excluding Black people from the political process, beginning with the disenfranchisement of African Americans in its 1890 Constitution to the use of literacy tests and poll taxes to prohibit voting until the enforcement of the Voting Rights Act of 1965.

The political activism put into motion by Freedom Summer sought not only to change the way Black Mississippians thought about their position in society but also to break down the barriers that kept them from participating in politics.

For nearly a century, segregation prevented most African Americans in Mississippi from voting or holding public office. The ingrained culture of segregation – which extended to housing, schools, workplaces and public accommodations – denied Black Mississippians access to political or economic power. Many Black Mississippians lived in dire poverty, indebted to white banks or plantation owners for whom they worked as sharecroppers.

Their daily life was kept in check by police and white supremacy groups such as the Ku Klux Klan as well as by the Mississippi Sovereignty Commission, a group that operated as a state-run spy agency during the Civil Rights Movement. African Americans who dared to challenge the condition imposed on them by white society were often killed, tortured, raped, beaten, arrested, fired from their jobs or evicted from their homes.

The organizers of Freedom Summer believed that bringing well-connected white volunteers from northern colleges to Mississippi would expose the conditions that Black Mississippians lived under. They hoped that media attention would make the federal government enforce civil rights laws that local officials ignored. Most important of all, Freedom Summer sought to educate Black Mississippians about their rights under the U.S. Constitution. To that end, the student volunteers launched Freedom Schools to teach children and adults black history, social studies, reading and math, as well as develop leadership skills, preparing them to become voting citizens.

Freedom Democratic Party

They also planned to help Black Mississippians organize a new political party that would be ready to compete against the mainstream Democratic Party after voting rights had been won. That was the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party.

Because Black Mississippians were barred from Democratic Party primaries and caucuses, they challenged the right of the party’s all-white delegation to represent the state at the Democratic National Convention (DNC) in August 1954. And since Black Mississippians were not allowed to vote, they held a parallel “Freedom Election” in November 1964 and challenged the right of the all-white Mississippi congressional delegation to represent the state in Washington in January 1965.

Fannie Lou Hamer after being beaten in jail, June 1963. Credit: FBI

Activist Fannie Lou Hamer’s impassioned plea for voting rights at the DNC was seen on national television by millions and epitomized Freedom Summer to many viewers. Hamer concluded her speech by saying “if the Freedom Democratic Party is not seated now, I question America. Is this America, the land of the free and the home of the brave where we have to sleep with our telephones off of the hooks because our lives be threatened daily because we want to live as decent human beings, in America?”

Despite Hamer’s valiant speech, as well as the strategic actions of other participants, including Freedom Summer leader Bob Moses, the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party was not seated at the Democratic National Convention in 1964. President Lyndon Johnson feared a white southern backlash if they were seated, and he used everything in his power to get the Freedom Democratic Party to stand down.

Political changes in the South

The backlash Johnson predicted did come, just not immediately. Eventually the Republican Party’s Southern Strategy led white Mississippi Democrats to change their party affiliation. Mississippi has not been represented in the U.S. Senate by a Democrat since January 1989, when John C. Stennis left office.

But the activism that was set in motion by the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party continued despite the setback from the party establishment. One of the places that spurred the activism of Freedom Summer was the town of Hattiesburg in Forrest County.

In 1964, Hattiesburg resident Victoria Gray Adams challenged Stennis for his seat, even though she did not have the right to vote. Stennis was a hardline segregationist as well as the last Democratic senator elected in Mississippi in 1982, before the state became a Republican stronghold. Although this challenge was ridiculed as a mock election by the Mississippi press, it was a very real challenge to Black Mississippians who took part. People like Victoria Gray Adams wanted to make the point that Mississippi would be a different place with Black voter participation.

Although the mock election or “Congressional Challenge” was dismissed as stagecraft, it did make white Mississippians aware that Black Mississippians would no longer accept a subservient role in the state’s politics. During Freedom Summer, more than 60,000 Black Mississippi residents risked their lives to attend local meetings, choose candidates and vote in the “Freedom Election” that ran parallel to the regular 1964 national elections.

Three Freedom Summer volunteers – Andrew Goodman, Michael Schwerner and James Chaney – were murdered because of their voter registration efforts. Despite the dangers, several hundred African-American families also hosted some of the nearly 1,500 volunteers who worked in Mississippi Summer Project offices scattered across the state. The volunteers were not just students: some were clergy sponsored by the National Council of Churches, attorneys recruited by the National Lawyers Guild and the Lawyers Constitutional Defense Committee and medical professionals from the Medical Committee for Human Rights.

Victoria Gray Adams, Freedom Summer, 1964, Herbert Randall Freedom Summer Photographs. Credit: University of Southern Mississippi

When news broke that Colom had won in Forrest County, many saw that win as significant since the county is named for one of the Ku Klux Klan founders, Nathan Bedford Forrest. Instead, I saw more of a connection to Freedom Summer as well as the activists who came out of Hattiesburg and Forrest County: Vernon Dahmer, whose house in Forrest County was firebombed, leading to his death, because he demanded the right to vote; sisters Joyce and Dorie Ladner, who participated in the Freedom Rides and sit-ins while students at Tougaloo College in Jackson; and of course, Victoria Gray Adams, a woman whose bravery and foresight about the power of the political process should be celebrated more.

But I also thought of Theron Lynd, the circuit clerk and registrar of voters for Forrest County, who systematically denied Black residents the right to vote by avoidance, hostility and dishonesty. Black residents were sometimes asked “how many bubbles in a bar of soap” on a literacy test in Forrest County.

It is equally important to examine the actions of the people like Lynd who resisted the changes the Civil Rights Movement demanded as it is to look at the work of activists. That is because there is a direct connection between those who sought to stop Black voting rights in the past and those who seek to reduce Black voter strength in the present. And the delays in Colom being declared the winner in this Senate race have everything to do with modern-day voter suppression.

Moving voters to inactive status

Before this year’s midterm elections, Mississippi’s secretary of state, Michael Watson, worked with the credit bureau Experian to “strengthen the integrity of elections” by moving people from the active voter rolls to inactive status in the state’s 82 counties. Yet, errors were rampant in the data used to remove voters from the rolls, according to reports.

In the days leading up to the elections, a coalition of national and state civil rights organizations warned Secretary of State Watson about this problem and requested that voters mistakenly ruled as invalid be reinstated. But in a manner much like the way Theron Lynd reacted to Black voters seeking to register in 1964, Watson never responded to the request. As a result, many voters were forced to use “affidavit ballots,” which delayed the final vote count in the Senate race. It is this thinly veiled attempt at voter suppression that may have led to the record turnout that led to Colom’s win.

While contemporary forces have sought to keep elements of Mississippi’s closed society in place, Mississippi was never absolutely closed off from the rest of the country, despite its politicians’ best efforts. There were always dissenters who kept Mississippi moving forward, many of them losing their lives in the process.

A long line of organizers and dissidents have been hard at work since Freedom Summer. Many of them have been at work since the Reagan era made Mississippi into a Republican stronghold, when he launched his presidential campaign by delivering a speech on states’ rights in the very county where the murder of three civil rights workers took place in 1964.

Colom’s election as senator shows that the legacy of Freedom Summer is very much alive in Mississippi. And while Colom alluded to the Civil Rights Movement and its martyrs, such as Medgar Evers, in speeches and his advertising, he maintained a campaign focus on the issues of the present, revealing, as the poet Charles Wright once observed, that living in history without living in the past is what the task is.


W. Ralph Eubanks is faculty fellow and writer-in-residence at the Center for the Study of Southern Culture at the University of Mississippi. He is the author of “When It’s Darkness on the Delta: How America’s Richest Soil Became Its Poorest Land,” as well as three other works of nonfiction.

Related Posts